Showing posts with label History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label History. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 31, 2023

An Ode to Ozymandias

One reason why I abhorred poetry was how open to interpretation it is. The more you submerge in it, the more you realise its multifacetedness. No wonder then that poetry is considered closer to other forms of 'fine' arts. Regardless, this greyness is the very reason I hated it. Parsimony and simplicity has always been my strong suite. And so, I never understood the fuss around poetry. I have long accepted my unpreparedness to appreciate this form of writing. Despite that, I have also realised over the years that there is still some kind of the free-flowing form which appeals to me. I will be unable to convey what about certain poems appeals to me (I wish I could wax lyrical :)), but maybe that's the whole point of poetry. That something undescribable is being described, and that creates ripples which are even more undescribable. 

In very general terms, if the writing makes me forget myself and makes me start imagining that specific milieu, that time, those characters, then that poet offers me a chance at an out-of-body experience. There are many a poets in India whom I love to death. My love for Sahir, Neeraj and Shailendra is amply displayed on this blog -- all masters of their craft, not only because of their ways with the linguistic jugglery, but because of how simple, accessible, and yet revolutionary they made this form to be. I think each of them was unique -- in the sense that each of them brought a very different structuring of the form that was absent in others -- that they revolutionised the discipline. Add to that, their punches were not gift wrapped in linguistic jugglery; it almost seemed as if they immolated in the fire of the unjustness of this world, and re-emerged from it with a steely determination, each in their unique ways, and articulated that so astutely, that they converted you into addicts, provoking you to consume more and more of their creations, taking you to newer and newer highs.

For example, read this one by Sahir:

जिन होठों ने इनको प्यार किया, उन होठों का व्योपार कियाजिस कोख में इनका जिस्म ढला, उस कोख का कारोबार कियाजिस तन से उगे कोपल बन कर, उस तन को ज़लील-ओ-खार कियाऔरत ने जनम दिया मर्दों को, मर्दों ने उसे बाज़ार दियाजब जी चाहा मसला कुचला, जब जी चाहा धुत्कार दिया...

these words...hurting you, hammering you, bringing you down piece by piece, knocking you down in submission in merely five lines...

This post, however, is not about Sahir. It's about someone else. If I have to choose one non-Indian poet, whose writings I gravitate towards, my unabashedly emotional vote will go to Shelley. I feel he was a true representative -- in his thoughts, creations and being -- of the Age of Enlightenment. Surprisingly, many things I dislike about poetry in general, e.g., subjectivity, I love about Shelley. His passion and the choice of words, his interpretation, his rejection of epics and odes to the gods and the rulers, and finally and maybe most importantly, his imagination, take his poetry to another level. It only helps that he was an atheist and rebelled against many social conventions.

One of the most lovely poems by Shelley is the sonnet 'Ozymandias'. Here is an example of how no pursuit, however cerebral or disconnected it may seem from the masses, exists isolated. One must read the background that prompted Shelley to write this poem. For Shelley to have written this poem at a time when kings and queens were no less than gods and goddesses, he challenged their very legacy in a mightily subversive manner. 

The poem goes like this:

I met a traveller from an antique land,

Who said—Two vast and trunkless legs of stone

Stand in the desart … Near them, on the sand,

Half sunk a shattered visage lies, whose frown,

And wrinkled lip, and sneer of cold command,

Tell that its sculptor well those passions read

Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things,

The hand that mocked them, and the heart that fed;

And on the pedestal, these words appear:

“My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings,

Look on my Works ye Mighty, and despair!”

No thing beside remains. Round the decay

Of that colossal Wreck, boundless and bare

The lone and level sands stretch far away.

 

Make of it what you may. In my view, at a personal level, nothing more humbling than reading this poem, especially every time your ego is acting up. At the societal level, I think the poem speaks about the tragic reality of imperialism. In a very meta-manner, this sonnet by Shelley, which rebelled against rulers for a more pro-people governance, must serve as a warning for all those very same democracies who ended their rulers and ushered in democracies (including the one which Shelley's sonnet helped in cementing), but ended up becoming inward-looking and myopic, by serving only their people and their land and their interests, at the cost to others, and to that end, they turned autocratic and parasitised, invaded and destroyed other civilisations. Shelley's sonnet should serve as a warning because it tells us, that this egoistic pursuit doesn't last in the long run, that this too shall pass, and a new order will arise. The lone and level sands will stretch far away once again...

Monday, January 02, 2023

Happy New Year!

Here's something to start the year.

If you are a word-nerd like me, who could have very well gone into studying languages rather than sciences* (only for my love for the genesis of words), here are some sites that are ultra-useful:

relatedwords.org

onelook.com/thesaurus

powerthesaurus.org

thesaurus.com 

etymonline.com

*I am terrible at speaking new languages, but reading and listening comprehension is good. I think that's due to the ability to trace the origin of things, asking the 'why' and the 'how' questions, as one has to do repeatedly in research. And so in the case of words, trying to trace the etymology of how they came to be, and why that combination of words to begin with. Actually, even before research came into life, this interest of tracing the genesis of words had already lit a spark. Our childhood games during dinner was when dad would ask us to guess meanings of very technical terms in Sanskrit/Hindi/Marathi/English, sometimes scientific terms, sometimes even genus and species names. And although it began as a game as a kid, there was this quick realisation that it's very useful to remember complicated scientific terms for exams.

Later, as I started research and teaching, it became quite clear that breaking down words is a very useful way of explaining complex terms to non-experts. It's also an interactive way of turning a word inside out, and quite fun. In fact, nothing compares with seeing the awe and comprehension on people's faces when you break down a lofty-looking unbreakable mass of alphabets, and say to them, don't worry, you sillies, it's just a compound word made of smaller words. It works even in case of commonly used big words, because unfortunately, no one taught us this skill in the school. Take the example of 'environment'. When you break it down, it becomes environment = en (in) + viron (turn/circle, from the verb veer) + ment (phenomenon) = the phenomenon of being enveloped. Doesn't that sounds almost magical? Okay, okay. Maybe not magical, but definitely interesting and revealing. Interesting enough to almost study the topic. Something that envelopes us needs to be studied, right?

The better part of this breaking down comes now. Closely related languages have common words. And many commonly used words in English actually come from French or Latin (or other languages), and so, it becomes that much easier to grasp those new languages if you were to be exposed to them suddenly the way I was. Reading French was made so much easier because it's crazy how many words it shares with English. And so, environment becomes environnement (but of course, pronounced differently than English). 

The best part, however, is this: many technical terms in science (and maybe other disciplines too) have been literally translated into Hindi (and maybe other Indo-Germanic languages too) (or who knows, maybe being from the same family of languages, the creation of words is independently similar in English and Hindi? Although this second explanation seems less likely to me). So environment = en+vironment+ment = परि (round/circle) + आवरण (envelope) = पर्यावरण . By the way, परि in Sanskrit/Hindi and Peri in Latin/English sound similar and mean the same, don't they? Well, turns out they are actually related. Check this out.

This is when the magic begins. You start wondering about the history and the geography and the movement of human beings as carriers of cultures and languages. You start wondering about who put the first string of alphabets together and how did it gain a critical mass to be understood and used; you start wondering whether languages be taught and learnt this way, and whether other subjects could be learnt this way; you start wondering is a common language a boon or a bane, and can having a diverse set of languages with diversity of rules around word formations and etymology reveal better ways of understanding, learning and communication? When you start asking such questions, a word doesn't just remain a word. It becomes a pearl that carries with it a secret from the past and, perhaps, a message for the future? A pearl of wisdom that's constantly moving and evolving and is a messenger of the history of time.

A very happy new year to you all!

Tuesday, December 03, 2013

Athens

I slept throughout my travel and woke up with a start as the Air France aircraft hit turbulence nearer to Athens. I believe AF flights take it as a personal pride when their aircrafts shake and shudder in mid air. In fact, there had to be a procedural plug on the dashboard to be pulled to scare shit out of all aboard. At that moment however, I was glad it made such a commotion, coz dying in sleep is cool only when you are old and wasn't my idea of how I wanted to die right then. If I had to die, I rather look the death in the face, so I leaned and looked out with anticipation.




Downtown Athens, though inland, is in close proximity to Mediterranean Sea, and the offshoots thereof, such as Ionian & Aegean Seas. The aerial view of these islands is as beautiful as the names of these seas. Athens is located on the Argosaronikos Gulf, and it makes for a stunning seascape.



Everything I thought I knew about Athens from the newspapers and hearsay, I threw it in the airport dustbin the moment I landed. Two reasons: It was cold. It was posh.I hadn't packed much in the way of winter. I should have known the limits of European definition of 'sunny and hot'. For me it was still chilly.

The great thing about the Athens Airport was that it is open. Paris is dark and cold and makes a bleak appearance. Athens on the other hand made for an appearance closely resembling the Greeks as I was about to discover. I guess, the way a city welcomes you can be taken as a proxy for its overall disposition. I love Paris. But the carefree, sunny, relaxed disposition that Mediterranean climate bestows on the Southern Europe is sourly missing in Paris.

Northern countries make for better infrastructure though as they are less relaxed. Airport-Downtown Athens metros are every 30 minutes. I missed the frequency of Metros in Paris.

While loitering aimlessly on the train station, I saw this and I kept staring...


No way! This was seriously snazzy! Could I actually read Greek if I tried? The Greek alphabets were riding the flashes of my memory and all the highschool and college Physics started unravelling in front of my eyes. The shapes started making sense. Alpha, beta gamma, delta...so on till omega. So, I didn't always understand what it meant, but I could still read it! Can you? Try and you will succeed. Many of these words are of course similar to English. I love linguistics, especially the ontogeny and etymology of words, and it was a treat, these four days, just to keep reading and making sense of shapes, and then words. Another common word on the train station...ΕΞΟΔΟΣ (or Εξοδοσ)...Can you read it? It says, Epsilon-Xi-Omicron-Delta-Omicron-Sigma...Exodos...or exodus on more commonly, exit in English!

After a long train ride, I reached the heart of Athens. I checked-in, took bath, stepped out, got some food, ate, took a nap and then went out for a long night walk.

Every nook, every corner, in fact every road had something that was lying there since last 2000 years. Much of it is subterranean as the modern city has been built over the ancient ruins. Instead of making complicated pathways leading tourists to the sites of underground ruins, the Greeks have devised an ingenious way of exhibiting their treasure to the tourists. You will see glass portals on the roads and pavements through which people can look. It's a crazy contradiction. So, on my left and right were H&Ms, GAPs, ZARAz, MANGOs and C&As of the world, and below me were stones dating back to the BCs of the world. Are you fucking kidding me?!

I kept walking and came across a crossroad where a fellow was singing some folk songs and playing something like a Mandolin. I lingered around. I sat on a stone (who knows how old it must be) and kept listening to his sonorous voice. Gentle breeze, air strung with the smell of pizza and bread, and dim white light streaming from someplace. I looked up to see where is this source of light, moved a block, and met with a dazzling demonstration of architecture sitting snugly on a distant hill which we all know as Acropolis and Parthenon!



Friday, January 27, 2012

Corner & Displace Thy Enemy...

Reading an interesting but disturbing book on Palestine-Israel conflict. The book starts with a quick historical recap, with a focus on last 200 years. It's a recap of a region and a community that was ostracised for centuries, and which behaved more or less in an equally ruthless way when they came to power.

In early 1900's lands were bought from Arabs in Syria, Palestine and Turkey by questionable means, and once that was done, the focus was to make sure that the landless Arabs do not get employment opportunities...the whole objective was to displace the Arab peasants and farmers of the region. Such hatred, such spite...To think that people who were doing this were the same people who were racially discriminated by Russians till then. They were pushed to live on the periphery of Russian cities, and were denied prestigious professions. A few years later, what do they do? They plan strategic evacuation of some land for their own habitation! In Theodore Herzl's (one of the leading zionists) words, "We shall try to spirit the penniless population across the border by procuring employment for it in the transit countries, while denying it any employment in our own country...Both the process of expropriation and the the removal of the poor must be carried out discreetly and circumspectly."

Should any cause be worth so much hatred, so much spite? Worth enough to repeat the same mistakes that were inflicted upon the subject till a few decades back? Today, when Israel cries wolf, it sounds hollow.